Socially Responsible Investing
Increasingly, investors seek to align
their personal beliefs with their financial actions.
Not so long ago, the phrase “socially
responsible investing” might have brought to mind environmentalists
keeping their investment dollars out of companies they believed to be
damaging the Earth or animal rights activists rejecting companies who
tested their products on harmless creatures.
As the socially responsibly investing,
or SRI, sector has grown, its definition has also diversified. Today the
phrase encompasses any investment strategy targeted at aligning an
individual’s portfolio with their personal convictions. The Social
Investment Forum’s 2005 Report on Socially Responsible Investing
Trends in the United States identified $2.29 trillion under
professional management involved in one or more of the three primary
socially responsible investment strategies.
Screening, shareholder advocacy and
community investing are the three most common SRI strategies. Screening
– the practice of choosing or excluding investments from a portfolio
based on the investor’s personal criteria – may be the most commonly
known. Individuals may choose to invest, for example, only in companies
headed by women or individuals of a particular ethnicity. Or, they may
choose not to invest in companies that conflict with their
personal beliefs. In addition to the traditional “sin” stocks of
gambling, pornography and alcohol, an investor’s “anti” list might
include tobacco, nuclear weapons, defense, companies with poor records
on labor relations or the environment, religious issues, animal testing
or any other issue.
Shareholder advocacy uses the voting
rights associated with stock ownership to promote change within the
company. Anti-apartheid organizations used this strategy to get
companies to pull out of South Africa in the early 1980s. Community
investing directs capital from investors to communities that lack
traditional financial services such as credit, equity, capital and basic
banking products – services that a community needs to grow and thrive.
According to the Social Investment
Forum’s study, socially screened mutual fund assets grew 15-fold over
the same 10-year period from $12 billion to $179 billion, outpacing the
growth percentage of the mutual fund industry, as a whole, in the U.S.
However, financial professionals who specialize in socially responsible
investing point out that excluding certain companies – or in some cases,
certain sectors – from an investment plan can result in potential
financial consequences. Performance, benchmarking, implementation and
diversification issues may make these investments more difficult to
evaluate. In some cases, that may mean an investor has to choose between
his beliefs and his bottom line.
If you do choose to factor your
personal definition of social responsibility into your financial plan,
keep that trade-off in mind. Trying to compare your SRI-screened
portfolio’s performance to general indexes like the Dow and S&P 500 may
not be accurate comparisons. The Domini 400 Social Index, run by KLD
Research & Analytics Inc., attempts to provide a SRI-related benchmark
but again, index results may not adequately reflect the result of
including or excluding specific investments.
If aligning your investments is
important to you, talk to your financial advisor about socially
responsible investment strategies and their potential impact on your
portfolio. If your objection to a company’s practices or politics
doesn’t keep you up at night, you may be better off donating cash or
time to the organization than weeding through thousands of investments
looking for a soul mate.
Michael S Wallman of The Wallman Financial
Group is a Registered Representative with Securities America, Inc.,
a Registered Broker/Dealer, member NASD/SIPC. Advisory services
offered through Securities America Advisors, Inc., A SEC Registered
Investment Advisory firm. Michael can be reached at 305-374-2134 or by
e-mail at
mwallman@wallmanfinancialgroup.com
website
www.wallmanfinancialgroup.com
Chamber member for over 10 years!